The Navy Years
Why Don’t You Do It Right the First Time?
Deming, a Navy captain, and a car with no wheels

In 1987, after fourteen years working for contractors, I went to work for the Navy at NAVFAC in Norfolk, sitting for the first time on the owner’s side of the table. Not long after I got there, quality became the big word all over the government and American industry, and the Navy jumped on the bandwagon with both feet. Those of us in construction got sent to one week-long quality course after another, and that’s where I first learned much about a man named W. Edwards Deming. If you grew up in the 1950s like I did, you remember when “Made in Japan” meant cheap. It meant tin toys, whistles, and trinkets that fell apart before supper. Then, somewhere along the way, that changed. By the time I was grown, Japan was turning out some of the best electronics and automobiles in the world, and Deming was one of the people who had shown them how.
I actually got to hear Deming speak once, right there in Norfolk. The Navy packed about four hundred of us into a big theater, and during the questions a Navy captain stood up.
“Good morning, Dr. Deming. I am in command of the Naval Air Rework Facility here in Norfolk—”
Deming stopped him. “The what?”
The captain repeated it more slowly. “The Naval Air Rework Facility.”
Deming looked at him. “WHY DON’T YOU DO IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME?”
The whole place came apart. Not long after that, the Navy stopped calling those places Rework Facilities and started calling them Naval Aviation Depots. I can’t swear Deming had anything to do with it, but everybody in that theater got the message.
Our own office got the message too, and it hit a lot closer to home. Up until then, the tradesmen who went out in the field and checked the contractors’ work were called inspectors. Now they became Construction Representatives, ConReps for short, and it was a lot more than a new name on the door. Under the new way of thinking, the contractor was responsible for quality control. The government’s job was quality assurance. The Navy started writing the Three Phases of Quality Control into its contracts, preparatory, initial, and follow-up, and the contractor was expected to check his own work instead of waiting for a government inspector to find what was wrong with it. My boss, Commander Wayne Tomiak, had tried to tell us this my second week on the job. He went around a staff meeting asking people what their job was, and when one of the inspectors said his job was to check the contractor’s work and make sure it met the plans and specifications, Wayne shook his head and said, “A noble effort, but dead wrong.” Now I understood what Wayne had been driving at.
I’ll be honest, though. I didn’t buy it at first. Neither did the ConReps, and neither did most of the construction managers. We had all spent years watching contractors, and letting them inspect their own work sounded like putting the fox in charge of the henhouse. What was going to stop some outfit from building any old crap and telling us it was fine?
Then a Navy captain came down to Norfolk to explain what the Navy was doing, and he asked us a simple question. Say you buy a new car. You drive it off the dealer’s lot, and a mile down the road the wheels fall off. Whose fault is that? The dealer’s? Yours, for not checking the lug nuts before you drove away? Of course not. It’s the manufacturer’s. The company that built the car is responsible for building it right, and nobody expects you to crawl underneath it with a flashlight before you sign the papers. Then he brought it back to us. When a contractor signs a contract with the Navy, he’s promising to deliver the building shown on the drawings and described in the specifications. He’s the manufacturer. He builds it, so he owns the quality of it. The government’s job isn’t to stand behind him and catch every mistake. It’s to make sure the system he’s using to catch his own mistakes actually works.
That was an epiphany for me. I had spent fourteen years on the contractor’s side of the table, and somewhere in the back of my mind I had always thought of the inspector as the guy whose job was to find what you did wrong. Now I was sitting on the owner’s side, and I could see it from both directions at once. Quality didn’t belong to the inspector. It belonged to whoever built the thing. Old habits die hard, mind you. For years afterward most of us still called them inspectors, and you’ll notice I still do. But the idea stuck. And years later, when I owned my own company, Tesoro, and it was my signature on those Navy contracts, that captain’s car became a whole lot more personal.
Want the next one?
Win a signed $66.66 hardcover of my first book, The Shithouse Engineer. Sign up for new stories and you're in the drawing every month. First winner picked December 10. Quit anytime, no hard feelings. (Well, mostly.)


