TGW Publishing HouseTrue stories by Dennis Gilbert
Text
← All stories

Building Tesoro

D-O-N-E. DONE!

Fluor, a ninety-page contract, and clauses that delete themselves

Tesoro Corporation · Norfolk, Virginia5 min read
Illustration for D-O-N-E. DONE!
Illustration created with AI.

A few years after Robin and I started Tesoro, our construction company in Virginia Beach, Fluor came to Norfolk. Fluor was a very large engineering and construction company, and they had become involved in a major Navy project associated with the Navy and Marine Corps Intranet, or NMCI. At the time, NMCI was one of the biggest information-technology programs the Navy had ever undertaken. The goal was essentially to connect hundreds of thousands of Navy and Marine Corps users and computers into one modern network, and Norfolk was going to be one of the major hubs.

The way Tesoro got involved with that work was interesting because it wasn’t simply a matter of Fluor putting several contractors out to bid and us submitting the low number. Clark Nexsen was the Designer of Record for the Norfolk NMCI build-out. By that time we already had a strong working relationship with Clark Nexsen because Tesoro had completed four or five projects on which they had been the Designer of Record. As I remember it, Fluor asked Clark Nexsen to give them the names of three Norfolk contractors they should consider for the work. Clark Nexsen recommended W.M. Jordan, Skanska, and Tesoro. That was an important moment for us. Tesoro was still a relatively young company, and we were being put in the same conversation with some very large, established Norfolk contractors.

Fluor interviewed our team, including Wayne Tomiak, Pete, Carl Hubbell, and me. They wanted to know who we were, what we could do, and whether we had the experience and organization to handle a project of that size. Clark Nexsen’s design was only getting started, so there wasn’t a complete set of plans and specifications that Fluor could hand to contractors and say, “Give us a lump-sum price.” Fluor wanted to do the work on a cost-plus basis, which made sense, because we would have to build the project while the design continued to evolve. Fluor ultimately selected Tesoro.

During negotiations with Fluor, we got along extremely well with their operations manager. He was good. We spent a lot of time together working through how the project would actually operate—what Fluor would do, what they expected from us, subcontractor choices, logistics, material handling and the other practical details that had to be settled before the work started. Everything was going fine until it was time to sign the contract.

Like every enormous organization, Fluor had contract specialists. The fellow handling our agreement had not been involved in all those operational discussions with us. I don’t remember his name, I don’t remember ever meeting him, and I never saw him afterward. He simply sent me Fluor’s standard contract. It was about ninety pages long.

We started wading through it and discovered whole sections that had absolutely nothing to do with building an NMCI hub for the Navy in Norfolk. Fluor was heavily involved in the massive nuclear cleanup at the Department of Energy’s Hanford Site in Washington, which probably explains why its standard contracting language included requirements dealing with radioactive exposure. Our proposed contract contained provisions about radiation-monitoring badges, employee medical monitoring programs and other requirements that made no sense whatsoever for the work we were going to perform. I wasn’t going to sign it.

So the contract started going back and forth. We remained cordial, but I would take his latest version, cross out entire sections in red ink and send it back by courier. Then another version would arrive as though I had never said anything, sometimes with even more paragraphs added. This went on for something like two months.

Eventually the Fluor operations manager heard that there was some sort of problem with Tesoro. That probably surprised him because we had already spent so much time together working through the real project. He got involved, shook his head at the contracting problem and said he would talk to them. Three or four days later another contract arrived. This one was down to roughly forty-five pages, which was progress, but it still contained provisions about radiation badges and employee medical programs.

Wayne and I got on the telephone with the contracts guy and pointed that out. He explained, “Well, any nonapplicable clauses are self-deleting.” Wayne and I looked at each other. Self-deleting? I had been dealing with contracts for a long time and had never seen a clause climb out of a contract and delete itself.

“Really? Self-deleting?” I asked. He assured me that if a clause didn’t apply, it simply wouldn’t apply. “Okay,” I said, “then we would like the nonapplicable clauses deleted before we sign the contract.” He reminded me that the project was getting ready to start and Fluor needed the agreement signed. “I know,” I told him, “but you have to send me a contract I can sign, and this isn’t one.”

The following week another version arrived. It was still about forty pages long, and some of the same radioactive material was still in it. By then Wayne and I were marveling at the whole process. Then the contracts guy called again. This time he was under pressure from his bosses and was insistent that I sign the contract he had sent. Wayne was standing next to me, and we had the contracts guy on speakerphone, so some of the Tesoro staff could overhear the conversation.

“But you have to sign it,” he said.

“No, I don’t.”

“But it’s Fluor’s standard contract.”

“I understand that. I’m the owner of this company, and I’m not signing it.”

“But you have to.”

That finally did it. “Look, I am DONE. D-O-N-E. DONE! And I’m hanging up now because I am DONE.” I hung up.

There was a moment of silence. Wayne chuckled. “I’m not sure that’s a winning method of dealing with clients.”

I was still irritated. Fluor was a terrific opportunity, but I wasn’t going to sign a contract that made no sense for the work we were doing. Wayne went to see the Fluor operations manager. I wasn’t there, so I don’t know what he said or exactly how he did it. Wayne was a levelheaded former Navy captain and our executive vice president, however, and he had a way of getting people back to the problem that actually needed solving. I don’t know what Wayne told them about me, either. Considering the telephone conversation they had just had with me, I probably didn’t want to know.

Whatever Wayne said worked. He sat down with the people involved, and before long that ninety-page monster had become a reasonable agreement of about twelve pages that we could live with. The operations manager got it through Fluor’s contracting organization, we signed it, and we went to work. The project was approximately $20 million, the biggest construction job Tesoro had ever taken on, and it became a game changer for us. For a company like Fluor, a $20 million project was important, but it was still one project among many. For Tesoro, it was everything. Fluor knew that if they gave us the job, they were going to get our complete and total attention. There wasn’t going to be some other $100 million project somewhere else taking up my time. This job was going to be our world. And it was.

Want the next one?

Win a signed $66.66 hardcover of my first book, The Shithouse Engineer. Sign up for new stories and you're in the drawing every month. First winner picked December 10. Quit anytime, no hard feelings. (Well, mostly.)