How It's Done
How a Lay Barge Puts Pipe on the Bottom of the Ocean
Tension, a long lazy S, and one forty-foot joint at a time

Introduction
Back in the 1970s, when I was working for McDermott, I did two stints on lay barges laying pipe on the bottom of the sea. Most people have never seen a lay barge and have no idea how you get a pipeline from a barge onto the sea floor, and when I went looking on the internet for an easy explanation, I opened about thirty pages and didn't find one. The engineering sites are written for engineers and the rest are trying to sell you something. Now, there's more than one way to lay pipe on the bottom. There's reel-lay, where the pipe is wound onto a giant reel and unrolled off the back of the ship like a huge garden hose, and there's J-lay, where the pipe goes down nearly straight from a tall tower for the really deep water, and a few others besides. But the one I'm going to explain is S-lay, where the barge is pulled ahead on its anchors, because that's the one I worked on in the North Sea. So here's how it worked, the way I saw it from the deck. The picture above is not any real lay barge. It's an AI illustration, made just to give you an idea of the basic parts of a lay barge and where they sit. And for all you folks who rode the lay barges out there, I know, I can count about forty things wrong with it, but I was trying to get this AI paintbrush to show the general idea so I could explain the basics to regular folks, so bear with me. Picture a barge about 400 feet long. The pipe comes aboard from the supply boat and is stored on the starboard side, the crawler crane down the middle moves it, and the numbers along the port side show the firing line, where each joint of pipe gets lined up, welded, X-rayed, coated and sent off the back of the barge over the stinger. Keep that picture handy, because we'll walk down that line one station at a time.
Preparation
Before a single joint of pipe ever gets to the lay barge, it gets ready on shore. The pipe comes in forty-foot joints, and each joint gets a thick coat of concrete around it at a coating yard. That concrete gives the pipe the weight it needs to stay down on the bottom, because a big empty steel pipe full of air would rather float than sink. The coating crews leave a short stretch of bare steel at each end of every joint so it can be welded later. Once the coating has cured, the joints get loaded onto supply boats and run out to the lay barge, a boatload at a time. When a supply boat comes alongside, the crawler crane lifts the joints off the boat one at a time and stacks them in the pipe storage bays on the starboard side, which on our barges covered that whole side of the deck. From there, the same crane carries each joint across the deck and sets it down at the head of the firing line, on the port side, where the hydraulic arms take over and line it up for welding. Laying pipe is a twenty-four-hour job, so the trick is keeping that pipe coming. If the supply boats fall behind and the racks run empty, the whole barge sits there waiting, and an idle lay barge costs a fortune every hour it sits. Here's the whole barge from above, with every station on the firing line marked, so you can follow a joint of pipe from the racks all the way off the back of the barge.

Tension
The whole problem with laying pipe offshore comes down to one thing. How do you take a 24-inch steel pipe off the back of a barge and lay it on the bottom of the sea without kinking it or breaking it? The answer is tension. It doesn't matter much how big the pipe is, a long string of it behaves a lot like a rope. If you just pushed a rope off the end of a barge, it would drop straight down and coil up in a pile on the bottom. Pipe does the same thing, only worse. Without tension it would kink, buckle and break right off the end of the barge, and you'd end up with a big pile of ruined pipe on the bottom under the stern, which is about as expensive a mess as you can make out there. And don't think that's just theory. I've seen it happen. Years ago in the North Sea, a lay barge lost its tension and the pipe did exactly that, and I ended up involved in the lawsuit that came out of it. Believe me, there's nothing like a pile of broken pipe on the bottom of the North Sea to get a whole lot of lawyers interested.
So how do you keep that from happening? Imagine somebody has hold of the other end of that rope and is pulling on it. Pull with just the right tension and the rope hangs in a nice gentle curve. That's what we did with the pipe. The far end was anchored on the bottom, the barge pulled away from it, and machines on the barge called tensioners held back on the pipe as it went out. The one place the pipe still wanted to bend too sharp was right at the back end of the barge, so lay barges had a long steel arm hanging off the stern called a stinger, with rollers along the top for the pipe to ride on. With the stinger holding it up at the top and just the right amount of tension in our rope of pipe, the pipe bends gently down over the stinger, runs pretty much straight through the water, then bends gently the other way and lays down flat on the bottom, easing into each curve and out again the way a railroad track eases into a turn. Look at it from the side and it makes a long, lazy S, which is why it's called S-lay.
Now here's where the anchors come in. A lay barge doesn't use engines to push it along while it's laying pipe. It sits in the middle of a big spread of anchors, two on each corner and two more off the bow, with steel wires running back to big winches on deck. Those anchors are what everything else works against. The barge winches itself forward on its anchor wires, and as it moves ahead, the tensioners hang onto the pipe and let it out slowly, so it doesn't fall to the bottom too fast. So you've got the anchors pulling the barge forward, the tensioners holding back on the pipe, and the pipe in between hanging in that long S down to the sea floor. Keep that balance just right and you lay good pipe. Lose it and you're back to that pile of broken pipe.

Welding
Now for the welding, and this is where that plan view comes in handy. You don't weld a pipeline all at once, you build it one forty-foot joint at a time, like an assembly line running down the port side of the barge. In the business that's called the firing line, though on our barges we just called it the line. It starts at the line-up station, about fifty feet long, where big hydraulic arms take a new joint from the crane, swing it into place, and line it up with the end of the pipe already going out the back, a lot like logs being lined up for the saw at a sawmill. Then the welding starts, and it's not one weld but several, laid one on top of the other. Back in the day it was stick welding all the way, a welder with a hood and a rod at every station. These days a lot of it is done by welding machines that ride around the pipe on a track, but the idea is the same. The stations are forty feet apart, exactly one joint length, so each one straddles a weld. The first station puts in the root pass, the bead at the very bottom of the joint that holds it all together, and it has to be perfect, because everything else sits on top of it. The next station puts in the hot pass, the next two lay in the fill passes, building the weld up layer by layer, and the last welding station puts on the cover pass, the finished outside bead you'd see if you looked at it. After that comes the X-ray station, and then the coating station. Remember that bare steel the coating yard left at each end of the joint? Now it gets covered. The crew wraps a tin mold around the joint and pours hot asphalt mastic into it, which fills the gap and protects the steel just like the concrete on the rest of the pipe. Then the finished joint moves on into the tensioners, about sixty feet of machinery that grips the pipe and holds it back, and from there it slides off the stern, over the stinger, and down into the sea.
So how does everybody know when to move? With lights. There's a board with a pair of lights for every station on the line, one red and one green. While a station is working, lining up a joint, welding, shooting the X-ray or pouring the asphalt, its light stays red. When that crew finishes, they hit a switch and their light turns green. Nobody moves until every light on the board is green. One red light, one welder still finishing his pass, and the whole barge waits on him. When the last light goes green, the deck foreman calls out "Pull pipe!" and the anchor winch operators go to work, hauling in on the anchor wires out front while slacking off the wires behind the barge, and the whole barge, all four hundred feet of it, moves forward forty feet and stops. Every weld on the line has now moved down to the next station, a new joint is waiting at the line-up station, every light goes back to red, and they do it all over again, joint after joint, around the clock.
Inspection and Moving the Anchors
Laying pipe isn't just about getting it on the bottom, it's about knowing it got there in one piece, so there were three kinds of checking going on all the time. The first was the X-ray. Every weld got shot, and the film showed anything you couldn't see from the outside, a crack, a little hole, a bit of slag trapped between the passes. A bad weld got cut out and done over, no arguments, because one bad weld is all it takes to ruin a whole pipeline. The second was tension. Gauges on the tensioners showed how hard they were holding back on the pipe, and somebody had to keep an eye on those numbers every minute we were laying. That's where I came in. The design group in London had sent out charts showing how much tension the pipe needed for each water depth, and my job was to work out the right number for where we were and give it to the superintendent. He and his crew ran the tensioners. I never touched a knob, I just did the calcs. As the water got deeper, the number went up, and if it drifted off, it got fixed fast. The third was the divers. They went down along the length of the stinger, where nobody on deck could see, and checked that the pipe was riding down the rollers the way it was supposed to, sitting in the rollers and not jumping out or riding up on the side, all the way to the end of the stinger. Between the X-rays, the tension numbers and the divers' eyes, we knew pretty quick if something was going wrong, and on a lay barge, knowing pretty quick is the difference between fixing a problem and paying for one.
Then there were the anchors. Every time the barge pulled pipe, it moved forty feet ahead, so the anchors out front got closer and the ones behind got farther away. Each anchor sat at the end of a two-inch steel wire, and each winch drum held thousands of feet of it, so the barge could pull ahead a long way on one set of anchors. But sooner or later the front wires got too short and the back wires got too long, and the anchors had to be moved. That was the tug's job. Every anchor had a lighter wire called a pendant running up from it to a buoy floating on the surface. The tug would come alongside the buoy, pick it up, haul the anchor off the bottom with the pendant, and carry it out ahead while the barge paid out wire, then drop it back on the bottom and let the barge winch it tight. The anchors behind the barge got picked up the same way and carried forward, leapfrogging, so the barge always had anchors out front to pull against and anchors behind to hold it steady. Moving anchors went on day and night, right along with the welding, and a good tug captain was worth his weight in gold, because if he dropped an anchor in the wrong place, or on top of somebody else's pipeline, you heard about it.
That's how a lay barge works. It's a whole lot of men, steel, wires and concrete all pulling against each other, and if everybody does their job, a pipeline goes down to the bottom of the sea one forty-foot joint at a time, in a nice lazy S, without anybody on shore ever giving it a second thought.
Want the next one?
Win a signed $66.66 hardcover of my first book, The Shithouse Engineer. Sign up for new stories and you're in the drawing every month. First winner picked December 10. Quit anytime, no hard feelings. (Well, mostly.)


