Building Tesoro
There’s Your Answer
A fire pump, an old fire main, and a fire chief who said it for us

Some time around 2005, Tesoro had a design-build contract with the Virginia National Guard for a brand-new maintenance facility at Fort Lee. We built it out of the ground. Half the building was offices, two stories of them, with bathrooms and the rest, plus a mezzanine that was really a half second story. The other half was the maintenance floor, open all the way to the roof, where the Guard would work on their trucks and equipment. Because it was design-build, the architects and engineers worked for us, which meant that when something went wrong with the design, it was ours to answer for. Keep that in mind.
Partway through construction, the commander came out to look things over, and he had an idea. He wanted a picture window put into his office so he could look down onto the maintenance floor and watch his people at work. It seemed like a perfectly reasonable thing for a commander to want. But somehow or another, putting that window in changed the fire protection requirements for the building, and the new requirements meant we had to install a fire pump. So our design people did what they were supposed to do. They went to the Guard and asked what pressure and how many gallons per minute they could count on at the fire hydrant on the street right outside the building. The Guard gave them the numbers in an email, our mechanical engineer designed the system around those numbers, and we built it. Everything was fine.
Everything stayed fine right up until the building was almost finished. One of the last things you do on a job like that is test the fire pump. You tell the system there’s a fire in the building, and the pump is supposed to kick on automatically and stay on. Ours kicked on beautifully. Then, after ten or fifteen seconds, it shut itself down, and the panel started flashing the same message over and over: protecting the pump, protecting the pump, protecting the pump. We fiddled with that thing for the better part of three weeks, and every time we ran the test, it did the same thing.
Meanwhile, the Guard wanted to move in, and they couldn’t. Without a working fire pump, there was no way to protect the people inside, and without that, nobody was going to give them a certificate of occupancy. So the people in charge of the Guard got upset, and pretty soon they insisted on a meeting. I knew exactly what that meeting was going to be about. They had a brand-new building they couldn’t use, and they wanted to know whose fault it was.
The meeting was held in a building right across the street from ours. On their side of the table were the head man from the National Guard, the base’s director of public works, a couple of his public works people, the public works mechanical engineer he’d brought along, and the fire chief for the whole base. On our side were me, our design project manager, our mechanical engineer, my project manager and my superintendent. We ran through the numbers. Our pump was telling us it wasn’t getting enough water, so it was shutting itself off before it burned itself up. Their answer was about what you’d expect.
“Well, you designed it wrong.”
So the two mechanical engineers, theirs and ours, put their heads together and spent the next ten minutes going over the specifications of that pump line by line. When they came up for air, they both agreed. The pump was the correct size for the sprinkler system we had installed in that building. That took care of the design. But we also had the receipts. Our design project manager had been on the job since day one, and she laid it out for them. Here’s the email. We asked you what pressure and what flow we’d get at that hydrant, you told us, and we designed to your numbers. The pump isn’t getting what you said it would get, and that’s why it’s shutting down.
“What do you mean it’s not getting enough water? It’s hooked up to the fire hydrant.”
All we could tell them was that it wasn’t getting enough water. That’s when the fire chief spoke up.
“Well, why don’t we just go test it?”
We all looked at each other. Okay. The fire chief got on his radio and called for a truck and a crew, and the whole meeting walked across the street to the building nobody was allowed to move into. There must have been eight or ten of us standing around that hydrant when the fire truck pulled up. The crew ran out some hose, put a nozzle on the end, hooked up to the hydrant and cranked it open. And sure enough, out came a good strong stream, thirty feet if it was an inch. It looked great. For about twenty or thirty seconds it looked great. Then it started to sag, a little at first and then more and more, until there was nothing but a dribble falling out about two feet from the end of the hose. I’ve seen garden hoses do better.
Now, we didn’t gloat, and nobody on our side said I told you so. We didn’t have to. The fire chief did it for us. He turned to the public works man and said, “Well, there’s your answer. We’re not getting any water in here.”
The Guard brought in their utility people, and it didn’t take them long to find the real culprit. The fire main running from the base pump house over to our building dated back to the early days of Fort Lee, older than anybody standing at that hydrant, and over the years the ground had shifted and pulled a lot of the joints apart. Whatever water was sitting in the line coming down the hill came out of that hydrant in a rush, and that was our thirty-foot stream. After that, the water was mostly going into the dirt through all those leaks, and our poor fire pump was sucking on an empty straw.
The Guard got a contract out, and about six or eight weeks later they called us back to test the pump again. They had laid brand-new steel pipe all the way in. We ran the test, the pump came on and stayed on, and it got all the water it wanted. They got their certificate of occupancy, they moved into their building, and that was the end of it.
So they searched for the guilty, and they found him. He’d just been lying under Fort Lee since before any of us were born.
Want the next one?
Win a signed $66.66 hardcover of my first book, The Shithouse Engineer. Sign up for new stories and you're in the drawing every month. First winner picked December 10. Quit anytime, no hard feelings. (Well, mostly.)


