TGW Publishing HouseTrue stories by Dennis Gilbert
Text
← All stories

Building Tesoro

The Most Expensive Fence in New Jersey

A Coast Guard fence, union wages, and a bid I never figured we’d win

Tesoro Corporation · Point Pleasant, New Jersey · around 20074 min read
Illustration for The Most Expensive Fence in New Jersey
Illustration created with AI.

Back around 2007, when I was running Tesoro, the Coast Guard asked us to bid on a little job up at their station in Point Pleasant, New Jersey. The fence around the property, maybe 120 feet of it, had fallen apart. The job was to tear out what was left of the old fence and put up a new one. Nothing fancy. Posts set in concrete, 2x4 stringers, and 1x6 boards, the same six-foot wooden fence you see around half the backyards in America. Not chain link, not cyclone, just regular old fence.

Now, any time you work for the federal government, you have to pay the Davis-Bacon wage rates, which are the minimum wages the Department of Labor sets for each trade in each part of the country. My estimator came back from looking them up with his eyes wide open.

“You’re not going to believe this,” he said. “Carpenters in that part of New Jersey get $57 an hour, plus another $18 an hour in benefits.”

“Well, that’s crazy,” I said.

That’s New Jersey for you. Most of the state is dominated by strong unions, and the Davis-Bacon rates tend to follow the union rates, which were sky high compared to what we paid folks in Virginia.

“Yeah,” he said. “So what do you want to do?”

I told him to figure out how many man-hours it would take and come back and tell me. He came back and said two of our guys could do the whole thing, demo and all, in about a week. Truth is, I didn’t really want the job. It was in New Jersey, it was a trip, and it meant somebody was going to be away from home for a week or two. So I told him to put it in for two weeks, two men, figure about 55 hours a week since nobody’s going to hang around a motel in New Jersey on the weekend doing nothing, and price the labor at $90 an hour. Then add in the materials, the truck, the hotel, the per diem, the phones and everything else, and put our overhead and profit on top of the whole pile. That was ridiculous, and I knew it. “Send it in,” I said. “If we don’t get it, that’s fine.”

Well, damn. We sent it in, and we got it.

And that’s when I got a little worried. When you win a bid you put in sky high, it means one of two things. Either none of your competitors wanted the job either, or they knew something about it that you didn’t.

Then I ran into my real problem. Back home in Virginia Beach we were paying our carpenters around $18 or $19 an hour. If I sent a couple of them up to New Jersey at the Davis-Bacon rate, my poor superintendent, who was on salary, would be making about half what the carpenters he was supervising were making. That’s no way to treat our supervisors.

So I thought about it, and I remembered I had several superintendents who came up the old way, as journeyman carpenters. I called two of them into my office.

“Look,” I said. “I’ve got a job up in New Jersey. It sucks. You’re in New Jersey and you’re away from home. But it’s 120 feet of fence. Tear out the old one, haul it to the dump, and put up a new one with the same stuff you’d buy at Home Depot. Four-by-four posts, two-by-four stringers, boards. It’ll take you a week, ten days at the most. And here’s the deal. I’ll pay you the Davis-Bacon rate for carpenters up there, which is $57 an hour.”

They looked at each other, and one of them said, “Well, hell yes. For $57 an hour we’ll do that.”

“Okay,” I said. “On the payroll you’re carpenters. But as far as the Coast Guard is concerned, you’re the superintendent and the assistant superintendent. It’s okay to be a working superintendent.”

“Yeah, that’s fine,” they said.

So we covered the jobs they were running here at home and sent them north. They did it in the ten days I said they would. And they made a ton of money, because on top of that hourly rate I was paying their hotel and their government per diem, which on the Jersey Shore was pretty rich. The Coast Guard paid for all of it, of course, because it was all in the bid.

As for whatever my competitors knew that I didn’t, I never did find out. Nothing went wrong. We made money, the guys made a lot of money, and the Coast Guard was real happy. They told us they’d never seen that kind of quality work in New Jersey. Ever.

Want the next one?

Win a signed $66.66 hardcover of my first book, The Shithouse Engineer. Sign up for new stories and you're in the drawing every month. First winner picked December 10. Quit anytime, no hard feelings. (Well, mostly.)